Thursday, January 27, 2011

'How Do You Know' doesn't seem to know itself


The film “How do you Know” stars Reese Witherspoon as a career softball player named Lisa, who, at age 31, was just cut from the all-American team. The explanation for her dismissal is that she is a tad slower than her fellow team hopefuls.

Lisa reels from being cut, and all she seems to do for the remainder of the film is take the “slow” insinuation to heart: she loses her focus and wanders around in an unshakeable fog that make many of her actions inexplicable.

Her first downfall is in starting a relationship with Matty (Owen Wilson), a baseball player for the Washington Nationals who is the epitome of many of the womanizing narcissists that we see in many pro athletes. Matty is too full of himself to respect Lisa, but she doesn’t care: he’s good for the purely physical relationship and she doesn’t want to bog herself down in a commitment.
That decision does not seem so out-there at first, since her commitment to the softball team had ended badly. She was just looking to take her mind off her troubles.

Almost as proof that she and Matty were just “friends with benefits,” Lisa agrees to go on a lunch date with George (Paul Rudd), who was set up with her through a mutual friend. George is also having a spell of bad professional luck. He recently received a document informing him that he was being indicted by the federal government for a wrong-doing at work.

So, the two sit in a fancy restaurant, each seemingly aware of the other’s job-related woes as one would be aware of a big elephant in the room; but, of course, they don’t address it. In fact, when George starts nervously rambling to Lisa at the restaurant because he is nervous about his feelings toward her or is just generally confused about the state of his life now that he is being indicted (or a combination of the two), she tells him to be quiet. She wants the two to sit in silence so she can clear her head.

The “elephant in the room” idiom (not addressing or ignoring obvious, looming truths) is, ironically, the best picture of how this film plays out. Many of the problems between the characters are never truly explained or thought through. Why does Lisa, who could possibly commiserate her woes with George, tell him to be quiet? If she doesn’t want to discuss her problems, she should have just stuck with Matty and not even bothered with George.

As for George, a federal case is made out of the fact that he is the target of…a federal case (investigation details are so bad that his secretary tells him she will be fired if she lets anything slip to him). However, the charge is never specified. Wikipedia’s explanation: he is “the target of a criminal investigation for criminal malfeasance.” Okay, then. It’s awfully lofty for a guy who seems like he tries to do well, but let a bad thing trip him up.

Perhaps Lisa’s telling George to be quiet was her way to try to regain power after her (and his) professional losses; a way to become more centered and move forward. But this is the only action in the film in which this could be an adequate description.

When the two meet back in his apartment in later days to talk, George pours his heart out about his feelings about life, people, his job woes, whatever, and all Lisa can respond with is “Huh?” or some other noise of incomprehension. Any moment between the two is lost. Lisa becomes so cloying that you want to yell, “snap out of it” to her mid-way through the film.

Lisa gains no more stability with Matty, with whom she decides to move in. Strange, again, as Matty has barely been able to distinguish her from one of his many other one-night stands (the man has closets full of women’s clothing so his conquests don’t have to leave his apartment to do the “walk of shame” with last night’s ensemble, for crying out loud). Now they love each other? It doesn’t take long for Lisa to realize that, gee, Matty is a self-absorbed jerk and she’s better off without him. So she leaves with her suitcases in hand and goes back to her one-sided chats with George (who, in another fuzzy plot point, may or may not be her new love interest).

“How do you Know” is as vague and frustrating as the question posed in the title (How do we know… what?) It is even more of an anomaly considering the leads. Witherspoon has found her niche in playing cute, bubbly girls who have to face obstacles and prove that they are tough cookies (who says cute girls are too weak to face their problems?) Simply think back to “Legally Blonde” where she played a ditzy sorority girl who managed to graduate Harvard Law School, or in her dramatic turn in “Walk the Line” as June Carter Cash, a woman who supported her country singer husband, but refused to be overshadowed by his fame. After considering those roles, it is hard to see why she chose Lisa, a woman who is completely unsympathetic in her actions and does not resolve to adequately solve her character’s problems by the end of the film.

As for Rudd, he comes close to playing his lovable average-Joe type (the man who isn’t the classic stud, but still manages to woo the ladies based on his charm and general cuteness), but considering George seems to have no more grasp on what a more positive direction for his life should be by the film’s end, he doesn’t quite endear as much as he should.

Finally, in the wasted talent category, we come to Jack Nicholson. Yes, THE Jack Nicholson is in this film as George’s executive father and boss. Normally, Nicholson has enough presence and clout to be mentioned much earlier in a review, but here he has been relegated bumbling old curmudgeon who seems to thrown his hands up at his son’s misfortune as if to say “what can I do?” He is not the rabble-rousing revolutionary we know from the likes of “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest” and other legendary works in the actor’s repertoire.

Alas, Witherspoon, Rudd and Nicholson can’t always play the same parts (but all three do niche performances so well). And perhaps these three wanted to try something different when they chose this script, but that “something” is not clear.

Overall, the film is flighty in every aspect of its development. Characters’ problems were brought up, but scarcely fleshed out, which is inexcusable for a nearly two-hour long film. It leaves more questions than answers, certainly what a film that seems to be billed as a light-hearted romantic comedy should never do.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Lyco theater gives memorable performance of 'Brighton Beach'


Lycoming College theatre director Grechen Lynne Wingerter said that her favorite part of putting a play together is when the actors first read through their lines; it is a time when she can “finally hear the characters in the actors’ voices.”

And, while watching “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” the second of Lycoming’s main stage theatre productions of the year, those voices come out loud and clear, especially from the play’s central character, 15-year-old Eugene Morris Jerome, played with fantastic energy by freshman Taylor Anspach, as he narrates the goings-on of his family in their cramped home in the Brighton Beach section of Brooklyn, N.Y.

Set in 1937, “Memoirs” is the first of playwright Neil Simon’s semi-autobiographical play trilogy which features the many stages of Eugene’s coming-of-age (“Biloxi Blues” and “Broadway Bound” follow).

Eugene keeps company with his headstrong mother, Kate (Alyssa Allen) who is always hot on his heels, reprimanding him for misbehaving; his older brother, Stanley (Chase Mack), age 18, whose story finds him trying to help out his family while discovering the adult perspective of right and wrong (and who, despite his difficult transition, receives fierce admiration from Eugene); his aunt Blanche (Molly Collier) who came to live with them upon the passing of her husband; Blanche’s two daughters, the youngest (and sometimes sickly) Laurie (Elle Ingarra) and the trying-desperately-to-be-independent teenager, Nora (Hannah Eyler); and finally the beleaguered father, Jack (Jesse Shade) who tries to keep the family together and be a father figure for both his sons and his nieces.

While comedy/dramas about families are about a dime a dozen in films and on television, there is something inherently heartfelt about the Jerome saga because they prove that a family’s love for one another is steadfast, no matter what curve balls life throws them.

The hardships that befall the Jeromes are many. Father Jack is unable to keep his second job selling noisemakers because the party supply store he works for went out of business. Stanley, whom the family depends on as a second source of income, is nearly fired as he tried to stand up to his boss (albeit immaturely—he swept dirt onto the boss’s shoes) who had been treating a co-worker badly following a workplace accident. Blanche, who all along had been trying to build herself as a strong, capable single mother following her husband’s death, is beginning to lose herself again after she fears Nora, who wishes to leave home (and high school) to pursue a career on Broadway, will be gone someday for good. Finally, Kate, who seems to have shouldered much of the family’s responsibilities to keep themselves together, is letting her bottled-up frustrations from trying to keep her rambunctious sons in line, being a good second mother to her nieces, and trying to support her sister’s re-emergence as an independent woman, get the best of her by frequently by bursting angrily at any little (or big) mishap her family seems to encounter.

Despite these many tribulations, there are moments of hilarity as well. Mostly, it is from Eugene, who acts like a teenage boy to a T. While it is obvious by his under-the-breath grumblings that he doesn’t like helping his mother with housework or eating the liver she prepares for dinner, it is equally clear that he has a strong admiration for baseball and girls. Whether he is turning a package of food into a makeshift baseball, catching and throwing it to himself while he receives cheers from an imaginary crowd, or not-so-discreetly dropping his dinner napkin under the table so he can look up Nora’s skirt, Eugene comically builds upon these interests throughout the story.

Eugene is perhaps the biggest reason why the audience automatically wants to root for the Jeromes to stay tightly knit. Their story is told through his eyes, and they are certainly those of a young teenager with the world at his fingertips; he holds many hopes and aspirations of being a writer or a professional baseball player. And he can only prosper by having his family, the ones who encourage him to dream, right by his side.

What is also great about the way Simon wrote “Memoirs” is that while Eugene connects with the audience in his narrative asides, the family’s inner-workings and dealings are made between themselves; the audience is merely privy to watching their highs and lows, their tears and laughter. But the fact that they are able to come out happily in the end shows that they grew not only individuals but as a group, which makes the conclusion to this story all the more sweet.

While researching a prior article on the theatre department, Wingerter and many of the student actors agreed that working on a Lycoming College theatre production was like being together with family; all become very close and supportive of one another. Seeing this demonstrated so well on stage makes “Brighton Beach Memoirs” an altogether perfect choice for the College to produce.

“Brighton Beach Memoirs” will continue to run Nov. 18-20, beginning at 8 p.m. in the Mary L. Welch Theatre. For more information contact the box office at 570-321-4048 or visit www.lycoming.edu/theatre/tickets.html.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

This 'Spelling Bee' is full of w-i-n-n-e-r-s


The Lycoming College theatre department kicked off what will be another phenomenal season with its production of the musical-comedy “The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee.” Performances continue this weekend, Oct. 7, 8, 9, beginning at 8 p.m. in the Mary L. Welch Theatre.

The play is about just what the title suggests, a spelling bee, which takes place in the fictional Putnam Valley Middle School. The contestants comprise of the kids you would find around any primary school: the overachievers who took part in Nationals and are coming to claim a local title: Chip Tolentino (Joshua Troxler) and Marcy Park (Taylor Lubsen); the resident word nerd, William Barfee (Chase Mack); the perfectionist, Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre (Christina Moliterno); the new girl, Olive Ostrovsky (Andrea Fitzsimmons), and the third-place finisher who made it to the Bee on a lark (first- and second-place had to attend a bat mitzvah), Leaf Coneybear (Taylor Anspach).

Rounding out the participants are three adults who have as much staked in the competition as the children do: Rona Lisa Peretti (Alyssa Allen), the amiable announcer who, as a girl, won the Third Annual Bee with the word syzygy (which means “the alignment of three celestial objects”); Vice Principal Douglas Panch (Kevin Milliard), returning after a five-year absence as a judge and word-reader, and Mitch Mahoney (Billy Reilly), a former convict on community service who serves as “comfort counselor,” handing out hugs and juice boxes as each contestant falls to an improper spelling.

You may be wondering what element of a spelling bee can possibly be fodder for a comedy, but the creative team of William Finn, Rachel Sheinkin and Rebecca Feldman put light-hearted and feel-good humor into every round.

As each contestant goes up to the microphone to receive and spell their word, we learn a little about his or her personal history and what brought them to the bee. We see Olive’s hopefulness as a newcomer to the world of competitive spelling, but feel her lament that her parents, a workaholic father who has failed to pay the $25 entrance fee in advance and a mother who is in India on a spiritual mission, are not there to see her perform. We feel sorry for Leaf that his parents and siblings jab him for “being not that bright,” but our hearts flutter when, in a moment of trance-like brilliance, he nabs the correct spelling of words (which are, more often than not, the name of a South American rodent, such as the capybara).

The contestants and judges have their quirks, from visual spelling techniques using “arm-writing” (as Logainne does) or the dance of a magical foot (William’s specialty) to the deadpan, yet hilarious deliveries of definitions and usage sentences by Vice Principal Panch (example sentence for “palaestra”: “Euripides said, ‘what happens in the palaestra, stays in the palaestra’”).

Adding to the humor value is that four audience members are called up on stage to be contestants in the Bee. During the Oct. 1 show, Dr. Edward Gabriel of biology and Dr. Philip Sprunger of economics were two of the contestants vying for a chance at spelling bee gold. While these contestants survive a few rounds with easy words, such as “cow” and “Mexican” (drawing ire from the “real” contestants who have to spell words like “staphylococcus”), they are usually called up multiple times in a row until they are forced out by a difficult word.

As a former middle school spelling bee contestant (though never lasting long enough to place at the top), I long for the days that good spelling was an exceptional talent. Now, being in college, it’s not merely a talent, but a mandate that goes along with such thrilling statements as “good spelling is the key to a top-notch job résumé.”

However, the ability of this play’s performers, all college “kids” themselves, to go back about 10 years to portray a younger, more excitable side to themselves is truly impressive and heartwarming. There are so many good memories from that time.

“The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee” is certainly equal parts humorous and heartfelt, but it is relatable as well. Who hasn’t experienced the nervousness of neck-and-neck competition? Who hasn’t wanted glory so much that they could taste it? Though this play appeals to the inner competitor of all of us, it gently reminds us that winning isn’t everything, and that not living up to the pressure of everyone’s expectations can sometimes be a good thing. From the peer pressures of middle school to the business pressures of adulthood, these are words that will help us survive all of the rounds of the game of life.